New Study Shows That Dogs May Be Better At Rationalizing Than Humans

Written by: Dina Fantegrossi
Dina Fantegrossi is the Assistant Editor and Head Writer for HomeLife Media. Before her career in writing, Dina was a veterinary technician for more than 15 years.Read more
| Published on May 27, 2018

Humans learn through imitation. From early lessons in walking and talking to more advanced tasks like operating a car; we tend to watch our peers, then mimic their actions.

While dogs have evolved to parrot some of our facial expressions, one scientist suggests they may be the more free-thinking species.

Laurie Santos, a cognitive psychologist at Yale University, demonstrated this theory at the 2018 Liberty Science Centre Genius Gala. Santos presented the audience with a box featuring a cylindrical handle on the side. Before opening the lid, she jiggled the handle a few times. She repeated this process twice before inviting a dog onto the stage.

Once again, she jiggled the handle and opened the box’s lid as the pooch watched intently. Santos then invited the dog to open the box himself in order to retrieve a treat placed inside. Instead of blindly following Santos’ lead, the dog sniffed the box carefully before popping open the lid with his nose, completely ignoring the handle.

It turns out the handle had no role at all in opening the box and was simply there to prove Santos’ point – that humans (and other primates) rely too heavily on imitation. She believes most humans would have followed her lead in opening the box, jiggling the handle before attempting to pop the lid.

“Sometimes we imitate too much; we are so prone to trust others that we kind of copy the things we see them doing, even when those things other people are doing might not be so smart,” Santos told Live Science.

Dogs, on the other hand, are not as likely to blindly follow humans or one another.

“Dogs are really good at learning from us, but they might, in funny ways, be better at learning from us than we are from ourselves,” Santos said. “They are less irrational in following our behavior than humans are.”

Comparing human and animal cognition patterns has allowed Santos to identify fascinating differences in the way we look at and interact with the world.

“We have developed this cognition that can allow us to do these amazing things,” Santos said. “But we’re not perfect; when you really look at our behavior, we have these ingrained tendencies that might be leading us astray all the time — I think that can be humbling.”


H/T to Live Science

Question for a Vet? Chat Online Now

The iHeartDogs Ask a Vet tool gives you access to verified veterinarians 24/7. Get professional help for your pup and feed shelter dogs now.

iHeartDogs is reader supported. Our articles contain affiliate links where we are paid a small commission for linking to a product at no additional cost to the reader.

Recent Articles

Interested in learning even more about all things dogs? Get your paws on more great content from iHeartDogs!

Read the Blog

Leave a Comment