Shelter Dog Meal Donation Count:

Learn More

Blue Buffalo vs. Jinx: Who Wins? [2023]

Written by: Ejay C.
| Published on September 15, 2023

In the world of premium dog food, Blue Buffalo and Jinx Dog Food are brands that many pet owners consider for their four-legged friends. This article dives into a detailed comparison of these two brands, focusing on key factors like ingredients, ingredient quality, protein content, price, and value, as well as recall history. Stay tuned to find out which brand might be the best fit for your dog’s nutritional needs.

Blue Buffalo vs. Jinx: An In-Depth Ingredient Comparison

Blue Buffalo Pros:

  • Whole Meats: Blue Buffalo often uses whole meats like chicken, beef, and fish as the primary protein source in their formulas. These are more natural, easily digestible, and more biologically appropriate for dogs.
  • “LifeSource Bits”: Blue Buffalo includes what they call “LifeSource Bits,” a blend of antioxidants, vitamins, and minerals, which are “cold-formed” to retain potency.
  • Fruits and Vegetables: Their recipes often incorporate a range of fruits and vegetables, providing essential vitamins and minerals naturally. Blueberries, cranberries, and carrots are among the common ingredients.
  • Grain-free Options: For dogs with grain sensitivities, they offer a grain-free line that substitutes grains with other high-quality carbohydrates like sweet potatoes.

Blue Buffalo Cons:

  • Use of Meal Meats: While whole meats are often the primary source of protein, Blue Buffalo does use meal meats (like chicken meal, and fish meal) in some recipes. Though high in protein, meal meats can be less digestible.
  • Recall History: The brand has faced multiple recalls in the past, which may make some pet owners wary, even though they’ve taken steps to address these issues.

Jinx Pros:

  • Organic Chicken: Jinx incorporates organic chicken as a primary ingredient in some of their recipes, a feature for those looking for organic options.
  • Plant-based Proteins: Jinx also utilizes plant-based proteins like peas, which can be beneficial for dogs with certain meat sensitivities.
  • Functional Ingredients: Beyond basic nutrition, Jinx includes what they term “functional ingredients” such as salmon oil for omega-3s, and chicory root for fiber and digestive health.
  • Limited Ingredient: For dogs with sensitivities, Jinx offers limited-ingredient recipes to minimize the risk of allergies.

Jinx Cons:

  • Price: The brand is generally more expensive per pound, partly due to its focus on organic and high-quality ingredients.
  • Limited Wet Food Options: Unlike Blue Buffalo, Jinx has a more limited range when it comes to wet food, which might not be ideal for dogs that require a softer diet.
  • Lower Protein: Jinx foods often have a slightly lower protein content compared to Blue Buffalo, which might not be ideal for very active or working dogs.

Protein Content

Blue Buffalo tends to have a higher protein content, mainly due to its reliance on whole meats and meat meals. This could be more appropriate for active or working dogs who require more protein for muscle repair and energy. On the other hand, Jinx leans more toward balanced nutrition, including a mixture of animal and plant-based proteins. While the protein content may be slightly lower, it’s balanced by other nutritious ingredients like sweet potatoes and chickpeas, providing a rounded nutritional profile.

Ingredient Quality

Both brands stress the quality of their ingredients but in different ways. Blue Buffalo emphasizes real meat, fish, or poultry as the first ingredient and the inclusion of beneficial fruits and vegetables. They also have specific formulas tailored for different life stages and medical needs, making it easier for pet owners to find a product that meets their specific requirements.

Jinx, on the other hand, focuses on the quality and functionality of each ingredient. The use of organic chicken is a significant advantage for those specifically seeking organic options. Their inclusion of functional ingredients for digestive health or skin and coat support adds another layer of quality to their products.

Grain-Free and Specialized Formulas

Both brands offer grain-free options, but Blue Buffalo has a broader range, including specific formulas targeted toward different life stages and health conditions (e.g., weight management, senior dogs). Jinx, being a newer brand, has a smaller but steadily growing range.


Blue Buffalo offers comprehensive information about each ingredient in its product line, allowing for a higher level of transparency. They provide specific details about the source of each ingredient, something that pet owners increasingly seek. Jinx also offers transparency but has a more streamlined ingredient list, focusing on fewer, higher-quality ingredients.


Compare Pricing & Discounts: Blue Buffalo vs. Jinx

Jinx 35% Off 1st Autoship See Current Pricing & Deals
Blue Buffalo 35% Off 1st Autoship See Current Pricing & Deals


Recalls & Lawsuits: Blue Buffalo vs. Jinx

When it comes to choosing a dog food brand, safety is a critical factor, and understanding each brand’s history of recalls and lawsuits can offer valuable insights. Let’s delve into the records of Blue Buffalo and Jinx to examine any safety concerns you should be aware of.

Blue Buffalo Recalls & Lawsuits

Blue Buffalo has experienced multiple recalls over the years. In 2007, the company voluntarily recalled some of its products due to melamine contamination, a toxic compound found in plastics and fertilizers. This recall was part of a much larger, industry-wide issue affecting several brands. Then, in 2010, they had to recall certain dog treats due to the possible presence of excessive levels of Vitamin D. Excessive Vitamin D can be toxic for dogs, leading to severe health issues including renal failure. Another significant recall took place in 2015, this time related to potential salmonella contamination, a bacteria that can cause serious digestive issues.

Furthermore, in 2018, Blue Buffalo settled a lawsuit concerning the labeling of their pet foods. The lawsuit claimed that the company misled consumers by stating their products were “grain-free” when they actually contained grains. Blue Buffalo settled the lawsuit but did not admit to any wrongdoing.

Jinx Recalls & Lawsuits

Jinx, on the other hand, has a relatively clean slate when it comes to recalls and lawsuits, particularly because it is a newer brand in the market. As of the information available, there have been no significant recalls affecting Jinx Dog Food. This could be attributed to the company’s rigorous quality control measures or simply the benefit of being a newer brand with fewer opportunities for issues to arise.

However, the lack of recalls does not necessarily mean that the brand is without any risks. Newer brands may not have had the time to demonstrate their reliability over the long term. Also, as the brand expands, the risk of experiencing a recall or lawsuit naturally increases a factor that prospective buyers should consider.

Transparency and Accountability

Both Blue Buffalo and Jinx emphasize their commitment to quality and safety. Blue Buffalo, following its series of recalls, has worked to improve its quality control processes and increase transparency. The company provides extensive information about each recall on its website and has taken corrective actions to prevent future issues. Jinx also stresses its focus on quality and safety, although it doesn’t have a track record of recalls to support or contradict these claims.

It’s worth noting that recalls are an industry-wide issue and can happen to even the most reputable brands. Recalls can be voluntary and may serve as evidence that a company is taking proactive steps to ensure the safety of its products. A history of recalls should not necessarily be a deal-breaker, but it is an important factor to consider.

Independent Testing and Reviews

Another aspect to consider is the availability of independent testing results and consumer reviews. Blue Buffalo, having been around longer, has been subjected to various third-party tests and reviews, helping to provide a more comprehensive view of the product’s safety and quality. For Jinx, the data is somewhat limited due to its shorter time in the market, making consumer reviews and brand reputation key indicators of its reliability.

In summary, Blue Buffalo has faced multiple recalls and a significant lawsuit, which have led the company to invest in improving its quality control measures. Jinx has not experienced any major recalls or lawsuits, but it’s a newer brand and its long-term reliability is yet to be established. Regardless of the brand you choose, staying updated on any future recalls or lawsuits is crucial for ensuring your pet’s safety.


Compare Pricing & Discounts: Blue Buffalo vs. Jinx

Jinx 35% Off 1st Autoship See Current Pricing & Deals
Blue Buffalo 35% Off 1st Autoship See Current Pricing & Deals

Our Verdict – Blue Buffalo vs. Jinx: Who Wins?

After evaluating Blue Buffalo and Jinx Dog Foods on the criteria of protein content, ingredient quality, and recall history, we lean towards Blue Buffalo. This brand offers a high protein content primarily from whole meat sources, making it more biologically appropriate for dogs. Blue Buffalo’s focus on natural fruits and vegetables for additional vitamins and minerals further bolsters its ingredient quality. While it is true that Blue Buffalo has had more recalls, these instances have led to improved quality control measures. Jinx, being a newer brand, has less of a track record in these areas. Therefore, based on our criteria, Blue Buffalo seems to offer a more balanced combination of high protein content and quality ingredients, although keeping an eye on future recalls for both brands is advisable.


Blue Buffalo vs. Jinx: Frequently Asked Questions

1. What kind of meat sources do Blue Buffalo and Jinx use in their dog food?

Blue Buffalo primarily uses whole meats like chicken, beef, or fish in their recipes. They also include meat meals for additional protein but focus on high-quality animal sources. Jinx uses a combination of animal and plant-based proteins, including organic chicken and sweet potatoes. The quality of meat sources is generally high in both brands.

2. Are Blue Buffalo and Jinx foods grain-free?

Yes, both brands offer grain-free options. Blue Buffalo has a specific line of grain-free dog foods under their “Freedom” and “Wilderness” series. Jinx’s recipes are also grain-free, focusing on using legumes and other non-grain carbohydrates as primary sources of energy.

3. How do the brands handle food recalls?

Blue Buffalo has faced multiple recalls in the past but has been transparent and proactive in addressing these issues. They have taken steps to improve their quality control measures. Jinx, being a newer brand, has not yet experienced significant recalls. However, both brands claim to have rigorous quality control processes.

4. Are these brands suitable for dogs with allergies?

Both brands offer hypoallergenic options. Blue Buffalo’s “Basics” line is specifically designed for dogs with food sensitivities. Jinx’s grain-free, soy-free, and corn-free recipes also make it a suitable choice for dogs with common food allergies.

5. What is the price range for these brands?

Blue Buffalo is considered a premium dog food brand and its prices reflect that. Jinx is also on the higher end of the price spectrum, especially given its focus on organic and high-quality ingredients. Both brands offer a variety of products at different price points to accommodate different budgets.

6. Are these foods available internationally?

Blue Buffalo is widely available in the United States and has limited international distribution. Jinx is currently more restricted, mainly focusing on the U.S. market, but they are looking to expand.

7. Do these brands offer wet food options?

Yes, Blue Buffalo offers a wide range of wet food options alongside their dry food varieties. Jinx currently focuses on dry kibble but may expand their product line in the future.

8. How do these brands incorporate fruits and vegetables into their recipes?

Blue Buffalo includes a variety of fruits and vegetables like blueberries, cranberries, and carrots to provide essential vitamins and minerals. Jinx also incorporates fruits and vegetables, although their focus is more on functional ingredients like chicory root and salmon oil.

9. Do these brands have a puppy-specific formula?

Both brands offer puppy-specific formulas. Blue Buffalo has a “Life Protection Formula Puppy” line, and Jinx also provides puppy-friendly options designed to support growth and development.

10. Do Blue Buffalo and Jinx have senior dog food options?

Yes, both brands offer senior dog formulas designed to meet the specific nutritional needs of older dogs. These formulas usually have adjusted levels of protein, fat, and fiber to support senior health.

11. Can I find these brands in common pet stores?

Blue Buffalo is widely available in major pet stores, grocery stores, and online platforms. Jinx is primarily sold online but is expanding its retail presence.

12. How do these brands handle sustainability?

Both brands are aware of the importance of sustainability but approach it differently. Blue Buffalo focuses on sustainably sourced ingredients. Jinx, while a newer brand, emphasizes its use of organic and non-GMO ingredients, though detailed sustainability initiatives are not as clear.

13. Do these brands offer prescription diets?

Blue Buffalo offers a line of veterinary diet foods available through veterinarians, designed to address specific health issues. Jinx currently does not offer prescription diet foods.

14. Do these brands use artificial colors, flavors, or preservatives?

Neither brand uses artificial colors, flavors, or preservatives. Blue Buffalo and Jinx prioritize natural ingredients and avoid common chemical additives.

15. Do they offer money-back guarantees?

Both Blue Buffalo and Jinx offer satisfaction guarantees. If you or your pet are not satisfied with the product, you can typically return it for a refund or exchange, though it’s best to check each brand’s specific return policy for details.

Compare Pricing & Discounts: Blue Buffalo vs. Jinx

Jinx 35% Off 1st Autoship See Current Pricing & Deals
Blue Buffalo 35% Off 1st Autoship See Current Pricing & Deals

Question for a Vet? Chat Online Now

The iHeartDogs Ask a Vet tool gives you access to verified veterinarians 24/7. Get professional help for your pup and feed shelter dogs now.

iHeartDogs is reader supported. Our articles contain affiliate links where we are paid a small commission for linking to a product at no additional cost to the reader.

Recent Articles

Interested in learning even more about all things dogs? Get your paws on more great content from iHeartDogs!

Read the Blog