iHeartDogs is reader-supported. When you buy via links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no extra cost to you.
Ollie vs Nom Nom is a common comparison because the two brands are some of the most popular freshly-made dog food options. Both brands are wonderful choices for dogs because they offer personalized diets with human-grade ingredients to ensure your pup gets nutritious, balanced meals.
If you’re having a hard time deciding which brand is better for your pup, we’ve compared the two companies based on several aspects so you can decide which one fits your needs better.
Freshly-Made Dog Food: What is it?
Freshly-made dog food is a type of pet food that’s made with whole, high-quality ingredients, aiming to offer a nutritious, well-rounded diet. This type of food focuses on high-quality meats, vegetables, fruits, and grains, which are minimally processed to retain their inherent nutrients.
Unlike traditional kibble or canned dog food, freshly-made dog food is lightly cooked to ensure it doesn’t lose its essential nutrients. Then, it’s typically refrigerated or frozen to maintain its freshness. Many freshly-made dog food brands offer personalized meals that are shipped to your door to enhance your dog’s well-being while offering them a tasty diet.
Overview of Ollie vs Nom Nom
Ollie and Nom Nom are just two of the many freshly-made options on the market. While they both operate similarly, they have lots of unique qualities.
Ollie
Ollie is a fresh dog food company that delivers customized, high-quality meals right to your door. Each recipe is formulated by a veterinary nutritionist and personalized to fit your dog’s needs. The meals are crafted with human-grade ingredients, including premium meats and fresh fruits and vegetables, with no fillers, by-products, or artificial preservatives.
The ingredients in this food are gently cooked at low temperatures to maintain their nutritional value and then portioned according to your pet’s profile, which considers factors like age, breed, weight, activity level, and health conditions. With Ollie, dog parents can take comfort in knowing they’re giving their pets fresh, healthy, and tasty meals designed for their specific nutritional requirements.
Try Ollie and Get 65% Off Your First Box
Nom Nom
Nom Nom is a leading freshly-made dog food brand dedicated to providing pets with nutritious, custom-tailored meals. The company offers high-quality, restaurant-grade ingredients in its recipes, which are formulated by veterinary nutritionists to ensure a balanced and healthy diet for dogs. Nom Nom’s meals include a variety of proteins such as chicken, beef, turkey, and fish, complemented by nutrient-rich vegetables and healthy grains.
These meals are minimally processed, gently cooked, and portioned according to each pet’s details, taking into account factors like age, weight, breed, activity level, and health status. Nom Nom prides itself on its commitment to pet health, offering not just high-quality, personalized meals but also probiotic supplements and microbiome testing kits to support comprehensive pet wellness.
Find the Perfect Food For Your Dog at Nom Nom and Take 50% off Your First Order
Nom Nom vs Ollie Freshly-Made Dog Food
Keep reading to find out where Ollie vs Nom Nom stand on the following aspects:
- Ingredients
- Customization
- Variety
- Convenience
- Price
- Storage
- Safety
- Customer Service
- Give Back
Ingredients
Nom Nom and Ollie offer unique formulas, but their ingredient quality is similar. Both use high-quality ingredients cooked at low temperatures to preserve the nutrients.
Ollie
Ollie’s recipes use a variety of high-quality meats as their primary protein sources, such as chicken, beef, turkey, and lamb. The company also incorporates nutrient-dense fruits and vegetables like sweet potatoes, peas, and spinach. They use superfoods such as chia seeds and fish oil, and they don’t use any fillers, artificial preservatives, or by-products.
Most of Ollie’s meat proteins are sourced from human-grade farms in the United States, except for lamb, which sometimes comes from free-range Australian farms. All produce, seeds, and oils are from U.S. farms. Check out Ollie’s website for a full ingredient list.
Nom Nom
Nom Nom also uses premium proteins including chicken, turkey, beef, and pork. They incorporate vegetables like carrots, peas, and potatoes, as well as healthy grains like brown rice. Additionally, they use natural supplements like fish oil and a nutrient mix designed by their veterinary nutritionist to ensure complete and balanced nutrition. Nom Nom doesn’t use any artificial colors, preservatives, or fillers either.
All of Nom Nom’s ingredients are sourced from trusted growers and supplies in the U.S. You can find a full ingredient list on Nom Nom’s website.
Winner: Tie
Both companies source high-quality ingredients from trusted sources so you can feel safe serving the food to your dog.
Customization
Both brands offer customization so you can receive recipes that perfectly fit your dog’s dietary needs. However, the questionnaire about your dog is different for each company.
Ollie
To get started with Ollie, you’ll need to fill out a quiz with your dog’s information, including their age, weight, breed, activity level, and allergies. Then, Ollie will recommend the best formula and portions based on your dog’s details. If you have any questions during the process, you can contact Ollie for assistance.
Nom Nom
Nom Nom works similarly by starting you off with a quiz that asks about areas like breed, weight, sex, age, and body condition. You can also indicate if your dog has special health conditions, such as allergies, digestive concerns, or joint problems. If your dog has a health condition that’s not listed, you can talk to a canine nutritionist at Nom Nom for help.
Winner: Tie
Ollie and Nom Nom have a similar sign-up process, asking almost identical questions about your dog’s lifestyle and needs. They use that information to suggest the best possible diet.
Variety
Since both companies are big on customization, there’s a variety of food products to choose from.
Ollie
Ollie offers five fresh food recipes: Chicken with Carrots, Lamb with Cranberries, Beef with Sweet Potatoes, Pork with Apples, and Turkey with Blueberries. If you only want to mix the fresh food with your current food to boost the nutrition, it’s easy to select a Half Fresh Plan.
The chicken and beef recipes also come in a baked food form, which is a kibble-like option that’s convenient to store while still retaining more nutrients than the average dry dog food. The baked food currently only comes in a mixed plan with fresh food.
Nom Nom
Nom Nom has four food recipes: Beef Mash, Chicken Cuisine, Pork Potluck, and Turkey Fare. You can choose between a full meal or half meal plan. They also offer some probiotic supplements to improve your dog’s digestion.
Winner: Ollie
While both have several great food recipes, Ollie has more choices, especially now that they’ve introduced their baked recipes.
Convenience
Both companies package the food using dry ice to keep it cold and ship it right to your door. They’ll keep shipping more food as long as you need, so you’ll never have to run to the store for dog food again.
Ollie
Ollie’s shipments arrive with detailed instructions on how to portion the food for your dog. If you don’t need a full package for your dog’s meals, you can use the included storage container and scoop for the extra food. All sealed packages should stay in the freezer, and before you serve them to your dog, move them into the fridge to thaw for 24 hours.
Nom Nom
Nom Nom’s food also needs to be put in the freezer whenever it’s not in use and then thawed in the fridge for 24 hours before serving. This company’s packaging is unique because it’s already divided into portions, so all you have to do is open the bag of thawed food and pour it into your dog’s bowl.
Winner: Nom Nom
Both companies ship right to your door in recyclable boxes while keeping the food cold, but Nom Nom’s food is slightly more convenient because it’s already pre-portioned. So, serving it to your dog will likely be easier and less messy.
Price
Both Ollie and Nom Nom cost more than most kibble brands, but that’s because they’re full of high-quality, nutrient-rich ingredients for your dog. For reference, many kibble brands cost between $1 and $2 per day.
Ollie
On average, Ollie costs $2 to $6 per day, with small dogs being on the lower end and large dogs being on the higher end. However, it greatly depends on your dog’s needs and the plan you buy.
Nom Nom
Nom Nom’s prices also vary greatly based on your dog’s specific needs, but it usually starts at around $3 per day for small dogs and $7 per day for large dogs.
Winner: Ollie
Ollie is slightly more affordable than Nom Nom, but both brands are a reasonable price for the quality you’re receiving.
Storage
The freshly-made food for both brands needs to be stored in the freezer and then moved to the fridge for 24 hours when it’s time to thaw. Both last about four days in the refrigerator.
Ollie
With Ollie dog food, you might not finish a full bag each meal. So, your first order comes with a free storage container and scoop to put the leftover food in. However, the container is a little bulky for small packages of food.
Nom Nom
Each bag of Nom Nom food is meant to be a portion for your dog. However, if you need to give your dog a partial portion or if your pup doesn’t finish their food, the bag it comes in isn’t resealable. So, you’ll need to find your own container to store the leftover food in.
Winner: Ollie
Even though Nom Nom’s bags are pre-portioned, Ollie has better storage because they offer a durable container to keep leftover food in.
Customer Service
Customer service is crucial for dog food companies because you’ll want to be able to get a hold of them if any problems arise with your order. Luckily, both Ollie and Nom Nom are great in this area.
Ollie
Ollie’s customer service team is reportedly responsive and available through email, phone, and live chat on their website. Customers have highlighted their helpfulness in answering questions, addressing concerns, and making necessary adjustments to meal plans. They want to ensure all customers are satisfied, so they’ll work with you to resolve any issues.
Nom Nom
Nom Nom also offers multiple ways to get in touch with their customer service, including email, live chat, and phone. They’ve been recognized for their commitment to customer satisfaction, willingness to answer in-depth nutritional questions, and their ability to accommodate specific dietary needs or changes to the meal plan. They also have veterinary nutrition experts available to consult about dietary concerns.
Winner: Nom Nom
Both companies have excellent customer service, but Nom Nom does a better job of getting you in touch with nutrition experts when needed.
Give Back
Like iHeartDogs, both of these companies care about giving back to animals in need.
Ollie
1% of Ollie’s profits go to rescues and shelters. They sometimes donate healthy meals to shelter dogs as well.
Nom Nom
Nom Nom doesn’t currently offer any give back programs.
Winner: Ollie
When buying Ollie’s food, you can also feel good knowing you’re helping animals in need.
Frequently Asked Questions: Ollie vs Nom Nom
How Do Ollie and Nom Nom Customize Meals for My Dog’s Needs?
Both companies use information about your dog’s breed, weight, age, activity level, and health status to customize meals. This includes adjusting portion sizes and recommending certain recipes based on dietary needs. Then, those personalized meals will be shipped right to your door.
How Often Do Ollie and Nom Nom Deliver Food?
Both companies offer flexible delivery schedules that you can adjust according to your needs. Common options include weekly, bi-weekly, or monthly deliveries. So, you’ll never have to run to the store for dog food again.
Is it Easy to Switch or Cancel My Plan with Ollie or Nom Nom?
Yes, both companies offer the flexibility to pause, modify, or cancel your subscription at any time, though it’s always best to check the specific terms on their websites or with their customer service. You should be able to adjust your subscription by logging into your account or contacting the company.
Is Freshly-Made Dog Food Safe?
Yes, when prepared correctly and balanced for a dog’s nutritional needs, freshly-made dog food is safe. It provides the nutrients of raw food without the added risks. However, it’s always important to ensure the food comes from a reputable source that uses high-quality ingredients and follows safe food preparation practices.
How Long Does Freshly-Made Dog Food Last?
Freshly-made dog food doesn’t have the same preservatives as commercial kibble, so it doesn’t last long. It can be frozen for long-term storage, but in the fridge, it typically lasts for less than a week. Most freshly-made food companies ship food to your door on a schedule to make sure it’s always high-quality and safe to eat. To make sure you’re storing it and using it properly, check the product’s instructions.
Is Freshly-Made Dog Food Expensive?
Freshly-made dog food is typically more expensive than traditional kibble or canned dog food because it often uses higher-quality, human-grade ingredients and involves less processing. However, many pet parents believe the extra cost is worth it since it provides more nutrients, personalization, and flavor than traditional dog food.
Choosing the Best Freshly-Made Dog Food
Deciding between Ollie and Nom Nom dog food all depends on your preferences and your dog’s needs. Both companies provide excellent nutrition to dogs of all sizes, ages, and dietary restrictions. To make your decision, decide which aspect matters most to you and go from there.
Ollie is slightly more affordable with more variety, but Nom Nom offers more convenience and improved customer support. Both companies have excellent ingredients, customization, and give back programs. So, no matter which one you select, you’ll be getting high-quality food that your pampered pup is sure to love!
Ready to start your dog on freshly-made food? Try Ollie or Nom Nom today:
- Find the Perfect Food For Your Dog at Nom Nom and Take 50% off Your First Order
- Have Your Pup Try Ollie and Get 65% Off Your First Box
Want to compare Nom Nom vs Farmer’s Dog vs Ollie? Check out our article about Farmer’s Dog and Nom Nom!
Toledo, United States.
