Shelter Dog Meal Donation Count:

Learn More

Science Diet vs. Nutro: Who Wins? [2024]

Written by: Arlene Divina
Arlene Divina, one of the content writers at IHD, loves going on adventures with her adorable fur baby. She now creates informative content for pet parents. Read more
| Published on January 3, 2024

In the world of premium dog food, Science Diet and Nutro have long been brands that pet owners trust and rely upon. As we delve into a comparison of these two giants, we’ll critically examine their ingredients, assess the quality of those ingredients, explore protein content, evaluate price and value, and consider any past recall histories that may influence a buyer’s choice.

Science Diet Vs. Nutro: An In-Depth Ingredient Comparison

  •        Science Diet: Pros of Ingredients

    • High-Quality Proteins: Science Diet often uses chicken or lamb as the primary protein source, ensuring that the product has a high-quality, easily digestible protein.
    • Beneficial Supplements: Many of their formulas include added vitamins and minerals, omega fatty acids, and antioxidants, which can support a dog’s overall health.
    • Natural Fibers: Their products often contain beet pulp, a source of soluble and insoluble fiber, which can aid in digestion.
  •       Science Diet: Cons of Ingredients

    • Grain Inclusion: Some pet owners might be cautious of products with corn, wheat, or soy, all of which can be found in certain Science Diet formulas. These can be potential allergens for some dogs.
    • Use of By-products: Some formulas may contain meat by-products, which, although not inherently bad, can be less nutritious than whole meat sources.


  •        Nutro: Pros of Ingredients

    • Non-GMO Ingredients: Nutro has a clear stance against genetically modified ingredients, which appeals to pet owners who are looking for natural food sources.
    • Farm-Raised Protein Sources: They often highlight the use of farm-raised chicken, lamb, or salmon as their primary ingredient, ensuring the quality of the protein.
    • Limited Ingredient Diet Options: Nutro offers products with a limited number of main ingredients, beneficial for dogs with allergies or sensitivities.
    • Clean Recipe Approach: Nutro prides itself on having no artificial colors, flavors, or preservatives, and no chicken by-product meal in their products.
  • Nutro: Cons of Ingredients

    • Cost: The emphasis on non-GMO and high-quality ingredients can make Nutro a more expensive option for pet owners.
    • Potential for Lentils and Legumes: Some of their grain-free formulas contain lentils and legumes, which the FDA has been investigating for a potential link to DCM (Dilated Cardiomyopathy) in dogs. However, it’s essential to consult with a vet about such concerns.

Comparative Analysis When pitting Science Diet against Nutro based solely on ingredients, several factors come into play. For pet owners who prioritize non-GMO ingredients and want a straightforward, clean ingredient list, Nutro seems to be the clear choice. Their commitment to farm-raised proteins and the absence of artificial additives resonates with a growing number of consumers.

On the other hand, Science Diet, backed by extensive scientific research, aims to tailor dog food to specific life stages and health requirements. This makes it easier for pet owners to select a product finely tuned to their dog’s needs, be it for puppies, adults, seniors, or dogs with specific health issues.

However, the inclusion of grains and meat by-products in some Science Diet formulas might deter pet owners who are particularly concerned about potential allergens or who opt for grain-free diets.


Compare Pricing & Discounts: Science Diet vs. Nutro

Nutro 35% Off 1st Autoship See Current Pricing & Deals
Science Diet 35% Off 1st Autoship See Current Pricing & Deals

Recalls & Lawsuits: Science Diet Vs. Nutro

Safety recalls are an unfortunate reality in the pet food industry, and understanding the history of such recalls can help consumers make informed decisions about what to feed their pets. Both Science Diet and Nutro have faced recalls in the past, which we will detail below.

Science Diet Recalls & Lawsuits:

  • In 2019, Hill’s Pet Nutrition, the company behind Science Diet, announced a recall for some of their canned dog food products due to potentially elevated levels of vitamin D. Excessive vitamin D can lead to potential health issues in dogs, including vomiting, loss of appetite, increased thirst, and other symptoms. The company acted quickly to address the issue and remove the affected products from shelves.
  • Earlier, in 2014, Science Diet had a voluntary recall for certain batches of their adult small and toy breed dry dog food due to potential contamination with foreign material, though no injuries or illnesses were reported.

Nutro Recalls & Lawsuits:

  • Nutro had multiple recalls in 2015. The first involved a limited number of dry cat food batches due to incorrect levels of zinc and potassium. This was a potential concern as incorrect mineral levels can lead to health issues in pets. Later that year, a small batch of Nutro Apple Chewy Treats was recalled because of potential mold contamination.
  • In 2009, Nutro faced a recall due to potential melamine contamination, a chemical that had previously been linked to pet food recalls in 2007. The company responded by discontinuing the affected products and ramping up their quality control processes.
  • Furthermore, in 2008, there were reports of mold in some bags of Nutro dog food, which led to a limited recall. The company addressed the issue and reinforced its commitment to producing high-quality pet food.

It’s worth noting that while recalls are concerning, they also demonstrate a company’s commitment to safety and transparency. Both brands have acted quickly to address issues when they arise and have taken steps to prevent future occurrences.

As for lawsuits, most major pet food companies have faced legal challenges at various times, often stemming from recalls or alleged product issues. Both Science Diet and Nutro have faced lawsuits in the past related to their products, but it’s essential to approach these with a discerning mind. For instance:

  • After the 2019 recall, Hill’s Pet Nutrition (Science Diet) faced a lawsuit alleging that elevated levels of vitamin D in their dog food led to illnesses and deaths in some dogs. The company acknowledged the recall and worked with affected pet owners to address concerns.
  • Nutro faced a class-action lawsuit in 2009 following reports from pet owners claiming that their pets became ill after consuming Nutro products. However, the FDA found no evidence of any contaminant in the food and did not identify a specific cause for the reported illnesses. The lawsuit was later dropped.

In summary, while both Science Diet and Nutro have faced recalls and lawsuits, it’s crucial to evaluate each incident in context. Both companies have shown a commitment to rectifying mistakes and ensuring the safety and quality of their products. As always, pet owners should stay informed and consult with their veterinarians when making decisions about pet nutrition.


Compare Pricing & Discounts: Science Diet vs. Nutro

Nutro 35% Off 1st Autoship See Current Pricing & Deals
Science Diet 35% Off 1st Autoship See Current Pricing & Deals

Our Verdict – Science Diet Vs. Nutro: Who Wins?

When comparing Science Diet and Nutro dog foods, several factors come into play. In terms of protein content, both brands offer formulas that meet or exceed the average protein levels found in most commercial dog foods. As for ingredient quality, Nutro emphasizes its commitment to non-GMO and real, recognizable ingredients, while Science Diet focuses on scientifically formulated, veterinarian-recommended recipes. Looking at recall history, both brands have had their share of recalls, though Science Diet’s vitamin D issue in 2019 was particularly concerning. Weighing these factors, we lean towards Nutro for its emphasis on natural and non-GMO ingredients. However, it’s crucial for pet owners to consult with their veterinarians to make the best choice for their individual pets.


Science Diet vs. Nutro: Frequently Asked Questions

  1. What is the primary focus of Science Diet and Nutro dog foods in terms of nutrition?Science Diet emphasizes scientifically formulated recipes that cater to specific life stages and health needs of pets. Nutro, on the other hand, stresses using natural, non-GMO ingredients and providing meals crafted from trusted farmers and suppliers.
  2. Are both brands grain-free?While both brands offer grain-inclusive options, they also have grain-free formulas available for dogs that require or prefer such diets.
  3. How do the protein contents compare between Science Diet and Nutro?Both brands offer high-quality protein sources, and the content varies by specific formula. Generally, they both meet or exceed the average protein levels found in commercial dog foods.
  4. Do these brands use real meat as the first ingredient?Yes, both Science Diet and Nutro typically list real meat as the primary ingredient in their formulas, ensuring a quality protein source for pets.
  5. Where do Science Diet and Nutro source their ingredients?Both brands prioritize sourcing high-quality ingredients. While Nutro emphasizes its commitment to non-GMO and recognizable components from trusted farmers and suppliers, Science Diet doesn’t specifically focus on non-GMO but ensures their ingredients meet their standard of quality.
  6. Are there formulas specific to puppies, adults, and senior dogs?Absolutely. Both Science Diet and Nutro offer a range of products tailored to different life stages, ensuring that dogs receive the nutrition they need at every age.
  7. How do the prices of Science Diet and Nutro compare?Both brands are premium dog foods, and their prices reflect the quality of ingredients used. The exact cost can vary depending on the specific formula and where you purchase it, but in general, Science Diet tends to be slightly more expensive than Nutro.
  8. Do either of these brands cater to specific health concerns, like joint issues or weight management?Yes, Science Diet is particularly known for its specialized formulas that cater to a variety of health concerns, from weight management to skin sensitivities. Nutro also offers some specialized formulas, although its primary focus is on clean, natural nutrition.
  9. How transparent are these companies about their manufacturing processes?Both Science Diet and Nutro value transparency and provide details about their manufacturing processes on their official websites and product packaging.
  10. Are there any preservatives or artificial additives in these foods?

Both brands avoid artificial colors, flavors, and preservatives. Nutro specifically highlights its commitment to clean ingredients, while Science Diet emphasizes the overall health benefits of its formulas.

  1. Which brand is more environmentally friendly?

Nutro often emphasizes its natural approach, and part of this is sourcing ingredients sustainably. Science Diet doesn’t focus its marketing on sustainability as much but being under the Hill’s Pet Nutrition umbrella; they do have initiatives for environmental responsibility.

  1. Do Science Diet and Nutro offer wet food options?

Yes, both brands provide a range of wet food options, offering variety and hydration benefits for dogs that prefer or benefit from moist diets.

  1. How do the brands handle recalls, and what is their history in this area?

Both brands have faced recalls in the past. Science Diet had a notable recall in 2019 related to vitamin D concerns, and Nutro has also had recalls, though for different issues. In each case, the brands took steps to address the situation and ensure pet safety.

  1. Are there any vegetarian or vegan options available in either brand?

While both brands primarily focus on meat-based proteins, Science Diet does have some vegetarian options available, particularly in their Prescription Diet line for specific health issues. Nutro primarily focuses on meat-based recipes.

  1. How do customer reviews compare between Science Diet and Nutro?

Both brands receive a mix of positive and negative reviews, as pet preferences and experiences can vary widely. However, in general, both Science Diet and Nutro are well-regarded for their quality and nutritional value, with many pet owners reporting positive outcomes for their pets’ health and vitality.

Compare Pricing & Discounts: Science Diet vs. Nutro

Nutro 35% Off 1st Autoship See Current Pricing & Deals
Science Diet 35% Off 1st Autoship See Current Pricing & Deals

Recent Articles

Interested in learning even more about all things dogs? Get your paws on more great content from iHeartDogs!

Read the Blog