Shelter Dog Meal Donation Count:

Learn More

Science Diet vs. Purina Pro Plan: Who Wins? [2024]

Written by: Arlene Divina
Arlene Divina, one of the content writers at IHD, loves going on adventures with her adorable fur baby. She now creates informative content for pet parents. Read more
| Published on January 3, 2024

Science Diet and Purina Pro Plan stand as two heavyweights in dog nutrition. This comparison will delve deep into their ingredients, quality, protein content, price points, and past recalls to help pet owners make an informed choice.

Science Diet Vs. Purina Pro Plan: An In-Depth Ingredient Comparison

Science Diet Pros:

  1. Natural Ingredients: Science Diet prides itself on its use of natural ingredients. Their products frequently list real meat, such as chicken or lamb, as the first ingredient, ensuring a quality protein source.
  2. No Artificial Preservatives: The brand stays clear of artificial colors, flavors, or preservatives, which can be a cause for concern for some pet owners.
  3. Nutrient Diversity: Many of their formulations include a variety of fruits and vegetables, providing a spectrum of vitamins and minerals essential for a dog’s health.
  4. Veterinarian-Formulated: Science Diet formulations are often developed with the input of veterinarians, ensuring that the nutritional needs of dogs are being met appropriately.

Science Diet Cons:

  1. Price Point: Given the premium ingredients and the research behind their products, Science Diet tends to be on the pricier side in comparison to other commercial dog foods.
  2. Grain Inclusion: While grains can be a valuable source of nutrients for many dogs, some formulas contain grains like corn, wheat, and soy, which can be problematic for dogs with specific allergies.
  3. Limited Protein Variety: While they do offer a range of proteins, some niche proteins beneficial for hypersensitive dogs might not be readily available.

Purina Pro Plan Pros:

  1. Diverse Protein Sources: Purina Pro Plan offers a broad spectrum of protein sources, from the typical chicken and beef to more exotic sources like salmon, making it easier for owners of dogs with specific protein sensitivities.
  2. Probiotics Addition: Several of their formulas incorporate live probiotics to promote digestive health, which can be a plus for dogs with sensitive stomachs.
  3. Tailored Nutrition: Purina Pro Plan has a variety of lines tailored to specific needs – from athletic dogs to those with sensitive skin and stomachs.
  4. Price Flexibility: With a broader product range, there are both premium-priced options and more affordable ones, catering to a wider audience.

Purina Pro Plan Cons:

  1. Use of By-products: Some of their formulas contain meat by-products. While not inherently bad, the ambiguity of the term “by-product” can be concerning for some pet owners seeking transparency in ingredient sourcing.
  2. Artificial Additives: Unlike Science Diet, some Purina Pro Plan formulas might contain artificial colors or preservatives.
  3. Grain-based Fillers: Some formulas lean on grains or grain derivatives as fillers, which can be a concern for dogs with grain allergies.

Comparison Insights:

When it comes to the battle of ingredients between Science Diet and Purina Pro Plan, it becomes evident that both brands have their strengths and areas of improvement. Science Diet leans heavily on its natural ingredient list and veterinarian-backed formulas, positioning itself as a premium option in dog nutrition. In contrast, Purina Pro Plan provides pet owners with a wide variety of options tailored to specific needs and budgets, with an emphasis on diverse protein sources and added probiotics.

However, the use of certain ingredients can be a sticking point for discerning pet owners. The presence of by-products and artificial additives in some Purina Pro Plan formulas, and the inclusion of potential allergenic grains in certain Science Diet recipes, can be points of contention.

Ultimately, the best choice will hinge on the individual needs of the dog and the preferences of the pet owner. For those who prioritize all-natural ingredients and veterinarian-formulated recipes, Science Diet might hold the edge. Meanwhile, those seeking diverse protein sources, probiotic inclusion, and a wider price range might find the Purina Pro Plan more appealing.


Compare Pricing & Discounts: Science Diet vs. Purina Pro Plan

Purina Pro Plan 35% Off 1st Autoship See Current Pricing & Deals
Science Diet 35% Off 1st Autoship See Current Pricing & Deals

Recalls & Lawsuits: Science Diet Vs. Purina Pro Plan

Both Science Diet and Purina Pro Plan, as major players in the pet food industry, have faced their share of recalls over the years. Analyzing these recalls offers insight into the safety and quality assurance measures each brand implements.

Science Diet Recalls & Lawsuits:

  1. 2019 Recall: Science Diet issued a voluntary recall for specific lots of their canned dog foods due to concerns over elevated levels of Vitamin D. An excess of Vitamin D can be detrimental to a dog’s health, causing symptoms ranging from vomiting to kidney failure.
  2. 2014 Recall: In this instance, Science Diet opted for a voluntary recall of certain dry dog foods due to potential salmonella contamination. This move was more of a precautionary step, as there were no direct reports of pets getting ill from the product.

Purina Pro Plan Recalls & Lawsuits:

  1. 2016 Recall: Purina had to recall a particular batch of Pro Plan Savory Meals due to inadequate levels of vitamins and minerals. The affected products were pulled off the shelves to ensure pet safety.
  2. 2013 Recall: Purina faced a recall for a potential salmonella risk in their Pro Plan and another brand’s dry dog food. While there were no reported illnesses directly tied to the dog food, the company took swift action to address the potential issue.

Purina Pro Plan Recalls & Lawsuits:

While recalls are relatively common in the pet food industry, given the stringent quality controls, lawsuits are more sporadic but have potentially larger implications.

Science Diet: In recent years, Science Diet hasn’t been a prominent target in major lawsuits related to their pet food products. This is not to say they’ve never faced legal scrutiny, but notable lawsuits have been minimal, suggesting a robust quality assurance process.

Purina Pro Plan: In 2015, Purina faced a lawsuit over allegations that their Beneful brand (another line, not Pro Plan) contained substances that could harm or even kill dogs. The plaintiff claimed that propylene glycol, an FDA-approved food additive used in the brand, was dangerous for canine consumption. The suit also alleged the presence of mycotoxins, harmful substances produced by mold found in grains. However, it’s crucial to note that Purina firmly denied the allegations, and the lawsuit was eventually dismissed.

Reflections on Recalls & Lawsuits:

Recalls and lawsuits in the pet food industry are serious matters. They not only affect brand reputation but also trustworthiness in the eyes of the consumers. Both Science Diet and Purina Pro Plan have faced recalls, but the nature and frequency of these incidents, as well as the response from the companies, should be considered.

Science Diet’s recalls, particularly concerning the excess Vitamin D incident, show the brand’s proactive approach to potential health concerns, even when the risk might seem minimal. Their transparency in these situations underscores their commitment to pet safety.

Purina Pro Plan’s recalls highlight a similar dedication to pet health. While the lawsuit concerning Beneful raised concerns, it’s essential to differentiate between different product lines under the Purina umbrella. Pro Plan, as a distinct line, has maintained a relatively strong safety record.

In the ever-evolving world of pet food safety, both brands showcase a dedication to upholding and sometimes exceeding the industry standards. Consumers should remain informed about any potential risks but should also recognize the considerable efforts these brands undertake to ensure the health and well-being of their pets.


Compare Pricing & Discounts: Science Diet vs. Purina Pro Plan

Purina Pro Plan 35% Off 1st Autoship See Current Pricing & Deals
Science Diet 35% Off 1st Autoship See Current Pricing & Deals

Our Verdict – Science Diet Vs. Purina Pro Plan: Who Wins?

Comparing Science Diet and Purina Pro Plan dog foods based on protein content, ingredient quality, and recall history gives a close competition. Both brands are reputable and known for their dedication to pet nutrition. Science Diet tends to offer a slightly more specialized formula for various dog life stages and medical conditions. On the other hand, Purina Pro Plan boasts a high protein content and a diverse range of formulas catering to specific needs. Examining the recall history, both have had recalls, but their transparent and swift actions reflect their commitment to pet safety. Given the nuances, we lean towards Purina Pro Plan for its slightly higher protein content and expansive range. However, the choice between these two largely depends on an individual dog’s specific needs.


Science Diet vs. Purina Pro Plan: Frequently Asked Questions

  1. What are the primary differences between Science Diet and Purina Pro Plan dog foods?
    Science Diet is primarily focused on providing nutritionally balanced formulas tailored to different life stages and specific medical conditions. Purina Pro Plan, meanwhile, emphasizes high-protein formulas with various product lines tailored to particular needs like athletic performance or weight management. Both offer a range of specialized diets for unique requirements.
  2. Do these brands cater to dogs with food allergies or sensitivities?
    Yes, both brands offer formulas for dogs with sensitivities. Science Diet provides sensitive stomach and skin varieties, while Purina Pro Plan has its Sensitive Skin and Stomach line. Both lines focus on limited ingredient formulas to reduce potential allergens.
  3. Which brand offers more variety in terms of protein sources?
    Purina Pro Plan tends to have a broader range of protein sources like beef, salmon, chicken, lamb, and turkey. Science Diet also offers multiple protein sources, but Purina’s selection is more diverse, especially in the Pro Plan range.
  4. How do the price points of these brands compare?
    Both brands fall within the premium dog food category, and their prices reflect that. However, Purina Pro Plan is generally more affordable than Science Diet, though prices can vary based on specific formulas and retailers.
  5. How do the protein contents in these brands compare?
    Purina Pro Plan, especially in its Sport and Performance lines, typically offers a higher protein content than most Science Diet formulas. However, both brands provide ample protein to meet a dog’s nutritional requirements.
  6. Do either of these brands offer grain-free options?
    Yes, both brands cater to the grain-free market. Purina Pro Plan offers grain-free formulas in its True Nature and Sensitive Skin & Stomach lines, while Science Diet has grain-free recipes in its lineup as well.
  7. What’s the recall history for these brands?
    Both brands have had recalls in the past, but it’s crucial to note that recalls are often voluntary and demonstrate a brand’s commitment to safety. It’s always a good idea to keep abreast of current recall information and not rely solely on historical data.
  8. Are these brands vet-recommended?
    Yes, both Science Diet and Purina Pro Plan are often recommended by veterinarians. Science Diet, in particular, is well-known for its vet-researched formulations aimed at specific health issues.
  9. Where are these dog foods manufactured?
    Both brands produce their dog food primarily in the United States, ensuring quality control and adherence to U.S. pet food regulations. It’s always recommended to check the packaging for specific details.
  10. Do these brands offer wet food options?
    Absolutely. Both Science Diet and Purina Pro Plan have wet food lines alongside their dry food offerings. This variety allows pet owners to choose or mix and match based on their dog’s preference.
  11. How do the brands address the nutritional needs of puppies and senior dogs?
    Both brands provide specialized formulas for puppies and senior dogs. Science Diet, for instance, offers Puppy Large Breed and Mature Adult lines, while Purina Pro Plan has Puppy and Senior-specific formulas to cater to the unique nutritional needs of these age groups.
  12. Do these brands use artificial colors, flavors, or preservatives?
    Both brands prioritize natural ingredients, but it’s always crucial to check specific product labels. In general, both Science Diet and Purina Pro Plan avoid unnecessary additives and focus on real meat, vegetables, and grains.
  13. How do these brands source their ingredients?
    Both Science Diet and Purina Pro Plan prioritize high-quality ingredient sourcing, often from trusted local suppliers in the U.S. They maintain rigorous quality control to ensure ingredient safety and quality.
  14. Do they offer therapeutic or prescription diets?
    Science Diet is particularly known for its Prescription Diet line, which provides therapeutic foods for various medical conditions. While Purina Pro Plan doesn’t have a prescription line under the same name, they do have a veterinary diet range called Purina Pro Plan Veterinary Diets.
  15. Which brand is more environmentally friendly in its manufacturing processes?
    Both brands work towards sustainability, but specific environmental initiatives can vary. For instance, Purina has initiatives aimed at reducing its environmental footprint, such as water conservation efforts. It’s always a good idea to research each brand’s latest sustainability initiatives to get the most up-to-date information.

Compare Pricing & Discounts: Science Diet vs. Purina Pro Plan

Purina Pro Plan 35% Off 1st Autoship See Current Pricing & Deals
Science Diet 35% Off 1st Autoship See Current Pricing & Deals

Recent Articles

Interested in learning even more about all things dogs? Get your paws on more great content from iHeartDogs!

Read the Blog