Shelter Dog Meal Donation Count:

Learn More

11 Best Indestructible Dog Toys For Heavy Chewers

Written by: Molly Weinfurter
Molly Weinfurter is a writer for iHeartDogs, and she’s passionate about helping animals in need. She volunteers for Bailing Out Benji and a local dog rescue.Read more
| Published on September 21, 2023
iHeartDogs is reader-supported. When you buy via links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no extra cost to you.

If you have a dog who loves to chew, you might be on the lookout for indestructible dog toys. Unfortunately, no dog toy is 100% indestructible, but there are lots of options that can withstand chewing better than others. With durable dog toys, you won’t have to replace them as frequently.

In this article, we’ll list some of the best dog toys for heavy chewers so you can find some long-lasting items for your playful pup. After all, your dog deserves to have fun, even if they destroy everything they play with.

Dog chewing durable toy

Buyer’s Guide: Indestructible Dog Toys

Dog toys that are indestructible (or close to it) are hard to come by, but by looking at the following features, you can find a long-lasting product.


Material has the biggest impact on a toy’s durability. Most dog toys for heavy chewers are made of natural rubber, reinforced nylon, or tough natural fibers. When choosing a toy, find one that’s made of materials that are appealing to your dog in addition to being durable.


Most durable dog toys come in several sizes, so choose one that’s suitable for your dog’s breed. The toy should be big enough that your dog won’t accidentally choke on it without being so big that it’s hard for them to grip onto.

Type of Toy

There are several types of durable toys. Most are chew toys, but there are also some mental stimulation toys and some reinforced plush toys. Some toys also have a flavor or scent to entice your dog. It doesn’t matter how durable a toy is if your dog won’t play with it, so choose a type of toy your dog will love.


Safety is a priority for all pet products. Make sure the toy doesn’t have any small pieces that could break off and become choking hazards. Regularly examine your dog’s toys for signs of wear and tear, then throw away any toys that are worn down a lot.


The best way to know how engaging and durable dog toys are is to look at reviews. See how long the toys lasted for other dogs to help you decide how long they might last for your furry friend.

Pit Bull with chew toy

Best Indestructible Dog Toys for Heavy Chewers

West Paw Qwizl
  • Works as a chew toy and puzzle toy
  • Made of durable, recyclable Zogoflex material
  • Great for holding bully sticks, dental chews, and jerky
  • Floats in water
  • Dishwasher-safe
  • Comes in three colors and two sizes

The Qwizl is one of several products made out of West Paw’s durable Zogoflex material. Dogs can use it as a chew toy or a puzzle toy because it has holes to hide treats or chews in. It’s perfect for long-lasting treats like bully sticks, dental chews, and jerky. The material is recyclable and dishwasher-safe while also being easy for your dog to grip onto. Plus, it floats in water, making it a great option for outdoor fetch sessions. It’s built for tough chewers of all breeds, so there’s a small and large size. If your dog loves this toy, you should check out some of West Paw’s other durable toys, such as the Toppl, Tux, and Rumbl.

Bark Shop Acornucopia
  • Provides mental stimulation for dogs
  • You can hide treats or kibble inside
  • Made of natural rubber
  • Unique texture on the top
  • Has an enticing peanut scent

The Bark Shop has a line of Super Chewer toys designed specifically for dogs who typically destroy toys. The Acornucopia is a popular option because it’s durable while also providing mental stimulation. It’s made of natural rubber and has a hole in the top to put treats or food in. So, your dog will have to roll it around to figure out how to get the treats out. Plus, it has a peanut scent and a unique texture to keep your dog interested even when the toy is empty. It’s ideal for medium and large dogs, and if you love this toy, you should check out some of the other Super Chewer toys in the Bark Shop.

iHeartDogs AgriChew Industrial Strength Dog Toy
  • Durable toy stands up to heavy chewers
  • You can smear peanut butter or a similar treat in the center
  • Cleans your dog's teeth as they chew
  • Bounces on certain surfaces
  • Dishwasher-safe
  • Donates toys to shelter dogs

The AgriChew is another great toy that can stand up to tough chewers, and many dogs enjoy the texture. You can smear peanut butter or a similar treat in the center to make the toy more interesting for your furry friend. When your pup is done playing with it, you can easily clean it in the dishwasher. The unique design of this toy also makes it a great dental product because as your dog chews, the toy can remove plaque and tartar, helping your dog have cleaner teeth. However, this toy should never be used in the place of teeth brushing. This toy bounces on certain surfaces, making it enjoyable for dogs who like to play fetch. Best of all, every time this toy is purchased, a toy is donated to a shelter dog.

KONG Extreme Tire Dog Toy
  • Made of KONG's most durable rubber
  • You can hide treats in the inner rim
  • Great for chewing or fetch
  • Bounces on some surfaces
  • Comes in two sizes

KONG is known for its highly durable toys, and the Extreme Tire Dog Toy is no exception. It’s made of KONG’s most durable all-natural rubber so it can stand up against heavy chewers. Not only does it withstand the aggressive biting force of power chewers, but it also offers an added layer of engagement by allowing pet parents to stuff the inner rim with treats or peanut butter. Plus, it bounces, so it can be used as a fetch toy in addition to a chew toy. It comes in two sizes so all dog breeds can enjoy it. If this rubber is too tough for your furry friend, KONG offers other toy options, including ones for puppies and senior dogs.

Chew King Dog Fetch Balls
  • Set of 8 durable fetch balls
  • 2.5 inches, but other sizes and sets are available
  • Made of natural rubber
  • Hollow center allows pet parents to put treats inside
  • Colors may vary

The Chew King Dog Fetch Balls are perfect for heavy chewers who love a good game of fetch. Made from high-quality, natural rubber, these balls are designed to stand up to rigorous chewing, making them ideal for dogs with strong jaws and an insatiable desire to bite. A distinguishing feature of these fetch balls is the hollow center, which can be filled with treats to add an extra layer of excitement and challenge for the pet. The balls’ resilience ensures they retain their shape over time, while their bounciness keeps play unpredictable and engaging. These balls come in a set of eight, so even if your dog chews through or loses one, there are plenty of others to use.

Benebone Bacon Flavor Wishbone
  • Infused with real bacon flavor
  • Made of tough nylon
  • Wishbone shape makes it easy to grip onto
  • Comes in four sizes
  • Benefits animal welfare organizations

The Benebone Bacon Flavor Wishbone is a dog chew toy that combines durability with irresistible flavor. Crafted from tough nylon, this wishbone-shaped toy is robust enough to withstand the persistent gnawing of heavy chewers. But what truly sets it apart is its deep infusion of real bacon flavor, making it almost impossible for dogs to resist. The shape allows dogs to get a good grip, enhancing their chewing experience. It’s available in four sizes so you can choose one that’s appropriate for your furry friend’s breed. Plus, Benebone donates a portion of its profits to animal welfare organizations, so you can feel good about your purchase.

Goughnuts Black Pro Ring
  • Designed by a rubber chemist with dog chew toy experience
  • Made of sturdy natural rubber with no weak points
  • If a red part is visible, the toy should be replaced
  • Company replaces toys under its lifetime warranty
  • Comes in four sizes

The Goughnuts Black Pro Ring is popular for aggressive chewers because it was designed by a rubber chemist who has over 30 years of dog chew toy experience. Thus, this toy is made of sturdy natural rubber with no weak points. If your dog chews far enough into the toy, you’ll find a red part, indicating that you should replace the toy for your dog’s safety. Luckily, the company is confident in the toy’s durability, so they will replace a destroyed toy at no additional cost. This toy is veterinarian-recommended, and it comes in four different sizes. The black toy with the yellow and blue dots is the toughest rubber, but there are other options for dogs that don’t need their toy to be quite so durable.

Playology Scented Dual Layer Bone Toy
  • Dual-layer construction for durability
  • Materials mimic the feeling of chewing on a real bone
  • Embedded with either peanut butter, beef, or chicken
  • Tested using US child toy safety standards
  • Comes in three sizes

The Playology Scented Bone Toy is made with a unique dual-layer construction to withstand aggressive chewers. It has a soft outer shell and a tough inner core to mimic the feeling of chewing on a real bone while still standing up to heavy chewers. It’s also embedded with a 100% all-natural scent that dogs can’t get enough of (either peanut butter, beef, or chicken). As your dog chews, the toy will release the enticing aroma, making them want to play with the toy more. Each toy has been tested using US child toy safety standards, and it comes in three sizes.

Tuffy Ultimate Tug-o-War Squeaky Plush Toy
  • Made with several layers of fabric and cross-stitched seams
  • Works great for tug-of-war
  • Includes three squeakers
  • Machine-washable and buoyant
  • Comes in four color patterns

If your dog is an aggressive chewer but only likes plush toys, finding something for them to play with can be tricky. The Tuffy Tug-o-War Squeaky Plush Toy is an option to consider because Tuffy makes some of the most durable stuffed toys. Tuffy’s toys are made with multiple layers of fabric and cross-stitched seams, offering an added layer of resilience against determined chewers. This toy’s elongated, dual-handled design is ideal for interactive play sessions, allowing dogs and their owners to engage in games of tug-o-war. As a bonus, the toy incorporates three squeakers, further captivating a dog’s interest and providing auditory stimulation. Plus, the toy is machine-washable and buoyant, so it can be a great choice even for outdoor activities.

Nylabone Power Chew Original
  • Made of tough, durable nylon
  • Helps clean your dog's teeth as they chew
  • Vet-recommended
  • Contains real chicken flavoring
  • Comes in five sizes

The Nylabone Power Chew Original is a simple bone design, but it’s a favorite among many dogs. Constructed from tough, durable nylon, this toy is formulated to withstand the force exerted by aggressive chewers, providing them with a safe outlet for their innate chewing instincts. It’s a vet-recommended toy because as your dog chews, the toy can help clean their teeth by scraping off plaque and tartar. It contains real chicken flavoring to appeal to most dogs, and it comes in five different sizes. It gives your pup something to chew on so they’re less likely to be destructive from boredom.

Planet Dog Orbee-Tuff Snoop Treat Dispensing Toy
  • You can hide treats or food inside it
  • Good for digestion and mental stimulation
  • Made of durable Orbee-Tuff material
  • Infused with mint oil
  • Floats in water and is machine-washable
  • Comes in several colors

The Planet Dog Orbee-Tuff Snoop is a mental stimulation toy that you can hide treats inside. Your dog will have to move the toy around to figure out how to dispense the treats. It’s also a great option for a slow feeder, which can benefit your dog’s digestion. This toy is made from the brand’s renowned Orbee-Tuff material, which is durable against heavy chewers while still being gentle on your dog’s teeth and gums. The material is also infused with mint oil to benefit your dog’s breath while they chew. It floats in water, making it a fun fetch toy for outside. Plus, it’s dishwasher-safe to ensure that it’s easy to clean. It’s a 5-inch sphere-like shape that comes in several colors.

Frequently Asked Questions

Are Any Dog Toys Truly Indestructible?

No dog toy is truly indestructible. While some toys are designed to be exceptionally durable and can withstand rigorous chewing from aggressive chewers, all toys will eventually show signs of wear and tear. It’s essential for owners to regularly inspect and replace toys as needed to ensure their dog’s safety.

What Materials Are Used in Indestructible Dog Toys?

Indestructible dog toys are typically made from durable materials like heavy-duty rubber, reinforced nylon, and sometimes tough natural fibers. These materials are chosen for their resilience against aggressive chewing and prolonged wear. Despite their toughness, it’s essential to monitor the toy’s condition and replace it when signs of significant wear appear.

Why Do Dogs Destroy Toys?

Dogs destroy toys due to their natural instincts to bite, chew, and tear, which can be traced back to their wild ancestors’ behaviors of hunting and consuming prey. Chewing also provides mental stimulation, relieves boredom, and helps in maintaining dental health. However, excessive or aggressive chewing can sometimes be a sign of anxiety, dental issues, or other behavioral concerns.

How Do You Know When to Replace a Dog Toy?

Replace a dog toy when it shows significant signs of wear, such as fraying, tears, or chunks missing. Any toy that poses a choking hazard should be removed immediately. Regular inspections of your dog’s toys will help ensure their safety during playtime.

Are There Indestructible Plush Toys for Dogs?

While some plush toys are designed with reinforced stitching, multiple layers of fabric, and other features to increase durability, no toy is truly indestructible. Yet, there are some plush toys that are strong than others. Even the toughest plush toys can be torn apart by determined chewers, so owners need to monitor their dogs during play and inspect plush toys regularly for signs of damage.

How Do I Choose the Right-Sized Chew Toy for My Dog?

To choose the right-sized chew toy for your dog, consider the size of your dog’s mouth and their chewing strength. The toy should be large enough to avoid swallowing or choking hazards but not so large that it’s difficult for them to grip and chew. Always consult manufacturer guidelines, which typically provide size recommendations based on dog weight or breed.

Dog with ice cream chew toy

Final Thoughts

Finding indestructible dog toys might not be possible since all toys can break with enough force, but choosing the most durable toys on the market can ensure that you don’t have to replace toys as often. If your dog is a heavy chewer, any of the toys mentioned in this article could be good choices for them. However, if your dog manages to break off small pieces of the toy, it’s best to take it away and buy a new one to keep your furry friend safe.

iHeartDogs is reader-supported. When you buy via links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no extra cost to you.

Recent Articles

Interested in learning even more about all things dogs? Get your paws on more great content from iHeartDogs!

Read the Blog